Busting open banking wide open

Myth: Most people are dissatisfied with their bank.

Busted: The majority of Australians are satisfied with their current banking products and providers.

Only between 5 to 9 per cent of account holders said they were dissatisfied with their account. Almost 80 per cent of transaction account holders are either satisfied or very satisfied with their existing provider. Similarly, three quarters of credit card holders and two thirds of mortgage owners reported being satisfied.

Myth: People make rational choices about switching banks.

Busted: People’s behavioural biases influence whether and how they search for information and make a decision to change provider. These behaviours include:

Improving people’s financial literacy, financial capability and financial consciousness helps them avoid these behavioural biases.

Open banking can help by enabling third parties to assist with the decision making process by making sense of the range of options or with making the potential benefits more tangible.

Ultimately it is important for both incumbents and challengers to create tangible benefits and communicate these clearly.

Myth: Switching is hard.

Busted: Almost half the individuals surveyed thought it would be easy or very easy to switch providers. Only 17 per cent thought it would difficult and just 5 per cent thought it would be very difficult.

For non-lending products such as transaction accounts, savings account and term deposits, the results were even stronger. Almost 70 per cent of people thought it would be easy or very easy to switch providers. Only 11 per cent perceived switching the provider of these products as difficult or very difficult.

Lending products, including mortgages, were different. Opinions were more divided on how easy it was to switch.

While 36 per cent of people thought it would be easy or very easy to switch mortgage provider, slightly more (43 per cent) suggested switching mortgages would be difficult or very difficult.

Across the generations, millennials (born between 1981 and 1996) generally perceived switching to be easier than other age groups. This is unsurprising as millennials are the age group most likely to search and to switch.

People who had switched providers in the past were more likely to rate switching as easy or very easy.

So, with the exceptions of mortgages, the difficulty of switching is not a factor which prevents most people switching banking provider.

Myth: People switch banks just to get a better price.

Busted: People switch banks for a range of reasons.

The primary reason why people switch banking providers is the pursuit of better value - in short, getting more for less. However, value isn’t necessarily the same as price.

Price is an important part of value: price factors were very important or important in choosing banking provider for 87 per cent of mortgage holders, 76 per cent of credit card owners and 74 per cent of transaction account owners respectively.

But price is not the only component. Perceptions of trustworthiness also impact perceptions of value. For all classes of banks, the survey showed customers choose to bank with the type of company in which they have the highest level of trust.

There are a number of other factors that also cause people to change their banking provider: service quality, product and service features, reducing complexity and relationship trust also influence consumers’ choices.

Value becomes less important for younger age groups; bank reputation, digital experience, prudential trust are also important for millennials and Gen Z.

Better product features such as offset accounts, interest free periods or interest only accounts can also influence that value that a consumer gets from their use of a banking product.

As people become more aware that their data has value and as their ‘ownership rights’ in the data they generate are strengthened through the consumer data right, people can decide to share their data (and their privacy) in exchange for value and benefits.

However, to successfully get customers to switch, banks and other financial institutions need to overcome customers’ inertia.

Changing customer’s behaviour can be hard but it starts with trust - a compelling proposition that delivers value and clear communication to the right target customers.

Paul Wiebusch is Partner, Open Data and Open Banking for Deloitte